Saturday, September 21, 2019

Review: The Beatles' 'Abbey Road Anniversary Edition' on Vinyl

Perhaps The Beatles didn’t intend Abbey Road to be their final album, but that’s the way things turned out, and it’s difficult to listen to the album and not take its finality as a conscious statement from the band that rearranged the face of pop. The Beatles were still rearranging it at the end with the ingenious medley that salvaged several of Lennon and McCartney song scraps.

More significantly, the songs point to where each Beatle would head during his solo career. Lennon exorcised his demons Plastic Ono Band-style with “I Want You [(She’s So Heavy)” and played the dreamer Imagine-style with “Because”. McCartney served up a neat pastiche with “Oh! Darling” and the kind of fluff that would cause critics to pile on him—often unfairly—throughout the seventies with “Maxwell’s Silver Hammer”. With “Octopus’s Garden”, Ringo delivered the good-natured tunefulness apparent in the band’s most surprising solo success. George also showed he had the stuff to make what could be the seventies’ greatest album—All Things Must Pass—with his first-rate contributions “Something” and “Here Comes the Sun”.


If there is a downside to Abbey Road, it’s that George Martin’s production may have been too polished, which raises an interesting issue when it comes to remixing the album for its 50th Anniversary. The most pristine Beatles LP probably would have benefited from a fresh coat of grit rather than a high-tech polish. Yet, Giles Martin’s re-mix renders the album even cleaner than his dad’s, with such distinct separation that you can hear every little element in each arrangement. Nevertheless, it is pretty exciting to hear Abbey Road with such spaciousness. That the younger Martin basically leaves the essentials of each song in place (the synthesizer still travels across the cans at the beginning of “Here Comes the Sun”; ditto for the lead guitar in “Sun King”) was a wise decision. However, such fidelity causes the rare instance of more noticeable changes to really stand out, and not always in favorable ways. Martin’s decision to pump up the backing vocals in “Here Comes the Sun” and reduce the bassy lead guitar in “You Never Give Me Your Money” can be forgiven even though neither move improves the song. His decision to make a hash of the fade out on “Come Together”, mixing in some sloppy alternate vocals and fading John’s screams and moans to near nothingness, cannot. By hiding those raw ad-libs, Giles Martin robs a lethargic track of its emotional climax.

I have few complaints with the rest of the Abbey Road Anniversary Edition, which finally brings The Beatles’ anniversary box set series in line with the growing enthusiasm for vinyl. For the first time since Apple/UMe began these sets with the anniversary edition of Sgt. Pepper’s, the vinyl set is identical to its CD equivalent (aside from the absence of the CD set’s hardcover book). The vinyl is super quiet, and the audio is excellent throughout. The bonus material on the second and third LPs is generally fascinating and consciously avoids overlap with the Abbey Road material on Anthology 3. Paul’s demo of “Come and Get It” appears in its original mix. George’s demo of “Something” includes the piano track erased from the Anthology mix (too bad the famed extended mix of the band’s version was not included, though). There is a take of “I Want You” with Billy Preston’s hot organ runs pushed up front, a warm acoustic guitar/drums/vocals take of “The Ballad of John and Yoko”, and a similarly stripped take of “Old Brown Shoe” that may be missing Paul’s incredible bass work but really shows off his terrific drumming. A demo of “Goodbye”, a light ditty Paul gave to Mary Hopkins, does the same for his lovely voice.

The coolest thing to pop up on this set is the trial mix of the Side B medley The Beatles nicknamed “The Long One”. The big story of this alternate version is that it reinserts “Her Majesty” between “Mean Mr. Mustard” and “Polythene Pam” (and we can hear why it was edited out of the final mix—it murders the momentum between two of the medley’s most dynamic pieces). The trial mix offers several other variations from the released mix: there’s loud cowbell on “Polythene Pam”, and the final three tracks are missing essential guitar, vocal, string, and horn parts. We hear those orchestrations isolated in the set’s final track, and they sound surprisingly ominous and not at all saccharine on their own. It’s a moody and stirring way to bring a most fab 50th Anniversary box set to the end.

All written content of Psychobabble200.blogspot.com is the property of Mike Segretto and may not be reprinted or reposted without permission.